Declining NAEP Scores Spur Progress in Literacy and Math Policy Across the United States

Alabama, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Maryland, Nevada, New Mexico, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas, Virginia

In 2025, state leaders continued driving bold reforms in K-12 literacy and math policy to advance student achievement. From banning harmful, ineffective three-cueing practices to providing guaranteed access to advanced math courses, states are prioritizing evidence-based policy solutions to help every student succeed.

This blog summarizes the K-12 literacy and math policy advancements states made during 2025 legislative sessions and explores emerging priorities for 2026.

2024 NAEP Results Show Decline in Student Achievement

The 2024 National Assessment on Educational Progress (NAEP) release in January revealed few bright spots in student reading and math proficiency across the country.

Since 2019, reading scores for fourth and eighth grade students declined by an average of five points. While fourth grade math scores show slight improvement since 2022, 2024 scores were three points behind 2019 scores. Eighth grade math performance was nine points below pre-pandemic levels, which is roughly a full grade level.

Results for 12th grade students were similarly concerning. NAEP 12th grade reading scores show a decrease of three points since 2019, with only 35% of students at or above NAEP Proficient. Declining results indicate that nationwide, readers are struggling well into their adolescent years.

International data mirror these same trends. The 2022 Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) showed 34% of U.S. students were low performers in math. Overall, U.S. students ranked 27th out of 81 participating countries in mathematics, highlighting the urgent need for stronger math preparation in order to compete on a global scale.

In response, state leaders took action during 2025 legislative sessions, advancing policies that better identify struggling students, provide timely interventions and strengthen teacher training in reading and math.

Why K-12 Literacy Policies Matter 

Research shows that students who cannot read proficiently by third grade are four times more likely not to graduate from high school.  Across the nation, states are implementing comprehensive literacy policies that ensure students receive high-quality instruction rooted in the science of reading to change that trajectory.

The science of reading is a vast body of research on how children learn to read. Evidence-based literacy policies emphasize the systematic and explicit teaching of foundational reading skills including phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency and comprehension. Effective policies are preventative and support all students as well as work to identify and support at-risk students as early as possible before they fall behind.

Explore quick summaries of the 2025 state actions that improved K-12 literacy policy for students below. 

2025 State Policy Actions Supporting Literacy 

Overall, 2025 state legislative sessions generated $52 million in new funding for literacy policy, and more than 3.7 million students nationwide will benefit from policymakers’ actions. Supports and interventions in states across the country will ensure students who struggle with reading have access to evidence-based resources and become skilled readers by the end of third grade.

The Fundamentals of Mathematics Policy 

Strong math skills empower students with the confidence and problem-solving abilities they need to make sense of the world and pursue future opportunities. Students who are confident, proficient mathematicians have more post-secondary education and career opportunities and are better equipped to make informed decisions throughout their lives.

In 2025, education leaders across the United States prioritized policies grounded in evidence-based instruction and early identification of struggling students. Several states also guaranteed access to advanced math courses for students who are ready to take on the challenge. Together, these principles help students build a foundation for lifelong success.

Explore quick summaries of the 2025 state actions that improved math education policies for students below.

2025 State Actions Supporting Mathematics Instruction 

In 2025, state actions generated $76 million in new funding for math, impacting more than 3.9 million students. Strengthening math instruction and supports for students nationwide will ensure more students build strong math foundations and stay on track for long-term success.

What’s Next for 2026 and Beyond 

As we move into 2026 legislative sessions across the country, we can anticipate states will continue to improve and expand their early literacy policies and tackle persistent issues with adolescent literacy. This important work does not stop in the early grades. Students need continued reading support, interventions and guidance throughout their K-12 journeys.

In math, we hope to see state leaders taking on the imperative task of raising students’ math proficiency levels with proven, evidence-based policies. We all want American students to succeed and be competitive in the global economy, and strong math skills are crucial to that mission.

Dive Deeper into Literacy and Math Policy Solutions with These Resources 

For an in-depth analysis of the early literacy and math policies in states across the country, explore Early Literacy Matters and Math Matters.

Listen to season 2, episode 3 of ExcelinEd’s Policy Changes Lives podcast where Lindsey Henderson, Senior Policy Director for Math at our sister organization ExcelinEd, sits down with Dr. Thomas Dee, Professor of Education at Stanford University, to explore what the research really says about Algebra I timing, readiness and state policy solutions. Then, be sure to follow up with season 2, episode 9, where ExcelinEd’s Dr. Kymyona Burk and Casey Taylor explore the “new frontier” in literacy policy: adolescent literacy.

Check out two episodes from season 2 of ExcelinEd in Action’s Statehouse Spotlight podcast. First, in episode 7, host Indiana Rep. Jake Teshka and I discuss the legislative effort aimed at strengthening math proficiency and numeracy across Indiana. Then, in episode 20, I talk with Pennsylvania State Rep. Jason Ortitay about early literacy reforms and the landmark literacy reform law that’s reshaping reading instruction across the state.

Read more from this blog series where we summarize which states took action on key policy trends reshaping K-12 education across the country.

References 

  1. Excelined.org – ‘Policy Lessons from States That Improved Students’ Reading and Math Proficiency’ Link: Policy Lessons from States That Improved Students’ Reading and Math Proficiency
  2. Nationsreportcard.gov – ‘NAEP Report Card: Reading’ Link: Explore Results for the 2024 NAEP Reading Assessment
  3. Nationsreportcard.gov – ‘NAEP Report Card: Mathematics’ Link: Explore Results for the 2024 NAEP Mathematics Assessment
  4. Nationsreportcard.gov – ‘NAEP Report Card: Grade 12 Reading’ Link: Explore Results for the 2024 NAEP Reading Assessment at Grade 12
  5. Oecd.org – ‘PISA 2022 Results (Volume I and II) – Country Notes: United States’ Link: PISA 2022 Results (Volume I and II) – Country Notes: United States
  6. Excelined.org – ‘Frequently Asked Questions: Comprehensive Early Literacy Policy’ Link: 2024 Comprehensive Literacy Policy FAQ One-Pagerhttps://excelined.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/2024-Comprehensive-Literacy-Policy-FAQ-One-Pager.pdf
  7. Aplusla.org – ‘Budget Watch FY 2026 | A+ Education Partnership’ Link: Budget Watch FY 2026
  8. Alison.legislature.state.al.us – ‘SB112 Introduced’ Link: SB112-int.pdf
  9. Azleg.gov – ‘Chapter 141 Senate Bill 1502’ Link: Chapter 141 Senate Bill 1502
  10. Azleg.gov – ‘Individualized education programs; dyslexia diagnosis’ Link: Individualized Education Programs; dyslexia diagnosis
  11. S3.amazonaws.com – ‘Senate Bill 25-200′ Link: Senate Bill 25-200
  12. Flsenate.gov – ‘SB 2500 Appropriations’ Link: SB 2500 Appropriations
  13. Flsenate.gov – ‘House Bill 1255’ Link: House Bill 1255
  14. Legiscan.com – ‘GA HB68’ Link: GA HB 68
  15. Legiscan.com – ‘GA HB307’ Link: GA HB 307
  16. Legiscan.com – ‘GA SB93’ Link: GA HB 93
  17. S2.amazonaws.com – ‘Senate Bill No. 1069’ Link: Senate Bill No. 1069 (2025) Literacy Intervention
  18. S3.amazon.com – ‘S.B. 460’ Link: Senate Bill No. 460
  19. Nmlegis.gov – ‘House Bill 156’ Link: HB0156
  20. Legislature.ohio.gov – ‘House Bill 96 Make state operating appropriations for FY 2026-27′ Link: House Bill 96
  21. Capitol.texas.gov – ‘Texas Legislature Online HB 2’ Link: Texas Legislature Online HB 2
  22. Excelined.org – ‘Math Policy’ Link: Math Policy
  23. Alabamaachieves.org – ‘Alabama Numeracy Act 2022’ Link: Alabama Numeracy Act 2022
  24. Flsenate.gov – ‘SB 2500 Appropriations’ Link: SB 2500 Appropriations
  25. Iga.in.gov – ‘House Bill 1634 Math Education’ Link: House Bill 1634 Math Education
  26. Legis.iowa.gov – ‘HF784’ Link: HF784_GovLetter.pdf
  27. Legis.la.gov – ‘Louisiana State Legislature HB 321’ Link: HB 321
  28. Marylandpublicschools.org – ‘Prek-12 Mathematics Policy Update” Link: Prek-12 Mathematics Policy Update
  29. Legislature.ohio.gov – ‘House Bill 96 Make state operating appropriations for FY 2026-27′ Link: House Bill 96
  30. Oklegislature.gov – ‘Bill Information for HB 1287’ Link: Bill Information for HB 1287
  31. Scstatehouse.gov – ‘South Carolina Legislature Online H 4025’ Link: H 4025
  32. Capitol.texas.gov – ‘Texas Legislature Online HB 2’ Link: Texas Legislature Online HB 2
  33. Lis.virginia.gov – ‘HB2686 School boards; certain advanced or accelerated mathematics opportunities’ Link: HB2686 School boards; certain advanced or accelerated mathematics opportunities
  34. Earlyliteracymatters.org – ‘Early Literacy is the Gateway to Lifetime Success’ Link: Early Literacy is the Gateway to Lifetime Success
  35. Shows.acast.com – ‘Policy Changes Lives, an ExcelinEd podcast’ Link: Math Policy 201: When should students take Algebra I or should they? | Dr. Thomas Dee
  36. Shows.acast.com – ‘Policy Changes Lives, an ExcelinEd podcast’ Link: Adolescent literacy is the new frontier in literacy policy | Dr. Kymyona Burk and Casey Taylor
  37. Shows.acast.com – ‘Excelined in Action Statehouse Spotlights’ Link: Advancing math education in Indiana classrooms | Rep. Jake Teshka
  38. Shows.acast.com – ‘ExcelinEd in Action Statehouse Spotlights’ Link: Tackling learning gaps with literacy reforms in Pennsylvania | Rep. Jason Ortitay

Solution Areas:

Early Literacy, Math Policy

About the Author

Ashley DeMauro Mullins is the National Legislative Director for ExcelinEd in Action. In this role, Ashley manages the organization’s Legislative Affairs team and works with leaders and lawmakers from across the states to promote student-centered solutions.